Electronic monitoring of near- and supercritical water based metal oxide nano-particle precipitation within ceramic micro reaction systems
The aim of the submitted project is to gain fundamental knowledge acquisition about chemical mechanisms, phase transition phenomena as well as nucleation and growth processes of metal oxide nanoparticles by using miniaturized sensors in combination with (further developed) simulation methods in reactive flow systems. In order to achieve this goal, it is necessary to realize a microreactor which has been optimized regarding sensor technology, flow control and dwell time for the synthesis of metal oxide nanoparticles in near / supercritical water. For this purpose, the microreaction system has to be optimized in to the effect that the system is equipped with numerous sensors, so that electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) can be used to monitor place- and time-resolved: a) the mixing process, b) the reaction process in (multi-phase) flows, and c) particle formation and growth with spatial and temporal resolution.
The implementation of the sensors into the reactor, the integration into the test station as well as the data analysis are carried out by WGs Türk und Hanemann. The simulation of the thermo- and fluid dynamic properties regarding the mixing and the calculation of the expected sensor signals is carried out in WG Greiner. The close interlocking of the different aspects "particle synthesis, microreactor design (MR), sensor integration, simulation of particle formation (PB) and particle growth (PW)" is illustrated in the following sketch:
Particle synthesis
One focus of the previous work was the conception, construction, commissioning and optimization of a test plant for the continuous hydrothermal synthesis (CHTS) of metal oxide nanoparticles under near- and supercritical conditions. In this work package, the CHTS plant was constructed with a functioning measurement, control and data acquisition system taking into account the special and necessary precautionary and safety measures required for the operation of plants under high temperature and high pressure (Tmax ≤ 723 K and pmax ≤ 40 MPa). Special attention was paid to the following aspects:
-
Low-pulsation operation of the plant under all process conditions, especially at high total mass flows of up to 80 g/min.
-
Simple and flexible combination of different mixer and reactor geometries. This enables the mixing and additive of different educt streams at various positions before and after the actual reaction zone for the work planned for the second advancement period.
-
Possibility of integrating the EIS measurement technology, based on the educt solution at all relevant positions for determination of the salt concentration and therefore the local (at various points in the plant) and final conversion (in the product solution).
Fig. 1 shows a schematic representation of the particle synthesis plant by CHTS set up in WG Türk. This test plant enables examinations under the following process conditions: 300 K ≤ T ≤ 723 K, 0.1 MPa ≤ p ≤ 40 MPa and 25 g/min ≤ ṁ3 ≤ 80 g/min. The mixing ratio (= cold metal salt flow / hot water flow) is in the range between 0.05 and 0.4 whereas the salt concentration, cSalt, is between 0.00125 and 0.15 mol/dm3, depending on the type of salt.
Fig. 1: Schematic representation of the CHTS facility for particle synthesis and course of the total mass flow over time. |
Based on our own results achieved so far and those from the working group of Tad Adschiri, it can be concluded in summary that the properties of the CeO2 nanoparticles produced by CHTS can be controlled as follows via process parameters pressure, mixing temperature, type of salt (Ce(NO3)3 vs. Ce2(SO4)3) and salt concentration:
This results in an increase of the reaction rate and to a lower solubility of salts what causes higher supersaturations of the aqueous solution. Both effects lead to the formation of smaller particles. This effect is also occurring by increasing the total mass flow ṁ3 and the simultaneous decrease in the residence time. Furthermore, the choice of the used salt as a precursor is also important. By using Ce2(SO4)3 instead of Ce(NO3)3 as a precursor (with the same process conditions) smaller particles can be synthesized. An increase of the salt concentration in the aqueous precursor solution, due to higher nucleation rates, leads to the formation of larger particles.
|
Fig. 2: Influence of the Re number on the median particle size. |
Design
In close coordination with the project partners, a reactor design was developed which allows the necessary requirements regarding nanoparticle synthesis, fluid dynamics, but also the manufacturability of the corresponding negative structure for shaping using mechanical microfabrication respectively various 3D printing procedures. In conclusion, the mould insert must allow the moulding of defect-free components using ceramic powder injection moulding. In addition to the actual mixer structure (T-structure), the mould insert also contains supplementary structures to enable the integration of electrodes for electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) for tracking nanoparticle synthesis. The CAD drawings of the reactor structure and the corresponding mould insert structures can be seen exemplarily (Fig. 3). When constructing the mould inserts, however, it should be considered that all dimensions on the mould insert have to be larger than the final dimensions in the reactor in order to compensate for the sinter shrinkage of the ceramic moulding compound. This mainly depends on the ceramic filling level of the inserted moulding compound. In the present case this concretely means that the moulded component must have a width of 1.8 mm in order to achieve the desired channel widths of 1.6 mm in the sintered component.
Fig. 3: Left: CAD reactor design, center and right: CAD mold inserts for replication.
|
Reactor fabrication
Powder injection moulding has been an established process for many years to produce ceramic or metallic components of different sizes close to the final contour cost-effectively and in large quantities and over the last 10 years, it has been further developed in the direction of ever smaller components, significantly increased precision and achievable minimum structure sizes well below 1 mm. Currently, lateral dimensions smaller than 10 µm, smallest structural details < 3 µm and dimensional accuracy ± 0.3% can be achieved in research operations. However, this is only possible if extensive research work is carried out at all individual steps in the process chain of moulding compound production, replication, debinding and sintering. The moulding compound production establishes the fundamentals for successful moulding and thermal post-processing. When selecting the moulding compound components (powder, binder, additives), attention has to be paid to ensure that no phase separation occurs under high shear loading. This could also be recreated using simulation calculations by WG Greiner in the past. In order to reduce the production time, plastic mould inserts were first produced for design studies using 3D printing (Fused Deposition Modeling, FDM respectively 3D InkJet/PolyJet process) in ABS (acrylic butadiene styrene) respectively in a thermosetting plastic and test moulding in powder injection moulding with a moulding compound containing 55 vol% aluminium oxide. After successful validation, brass forming tools were manufactured micromechanically (Fig. 4).
Fig. 4: Left: Mould inserts made of ABS, centre: ABS mould insert integrated in injection moulding tool, right: brass mould insert. |
After moulding, following debinding and sintering, the reactor halves were sintered with the aid of glass solder and prepared for installation into the CHTS plant using an adapter (Fig. 5).
Fig. 5: Left: Reactor green bodies after moulding, centre: joined aluminium oxide reactor, right: enclosed and sealed reactor. |
Sensor structure
For the construction of the sensor, electrodes had to be attached in pairs to the side; this was carried out after sintering the two reactor halves using a silver-containing epoxy 2-component-adhesive. A schematic cross section through the reactor is shown in Fig. 6, on the left. The positioning of the electrodes is a compromise between the requirements of the measurement technology and the operating conditions of the reactor: From the point of view of EIS, the electrodes have to be brought as close as possible to the reaction channel; from the point of view of the planned reaction conditions (pressure up to 35 MPa, T up to 750 K), the walls must be as solid as possible so that the reactor is pressure-resistant. A completely contacted ceramic reactor is shown in Fig. 6, on the right.
Fig. 6: Schematic cross-section through the reactor (left), completely contacted ceramic reactor (right). |
In order to verify the fundamental suitability of EIS for the detection of small salt concentrations, the change in impedance with sodium chloride concentration in water was determined using an electrically and fluid-contacted 3D-printed microreactor made of polyethylene terephalate (PET) (Fig. 7).
Fig. 7: Left: By FDM printed and contacted PET reactor, right: Impedance change as a function of sodium chloride concentration in H2O. |
Work program for the second phase 2020-2022
Simulation
In the following scheme the procedure of the simulation of particle formation during the continuous hydrothermal synthesis (CHTS) is shown:
Fig. 8: Procedure for simulation of particle formation
The simulation can be divided into three single steps. First, the flow and temperature fields inside the reactor are simulated and characterized. After that the reaction and particle formation through precipitation can be simulated. Hereby, the flow field and the reaction can be simulated by applying a single-phase model. In contrast to that, the precipitation has to be simulated with a multiphase model.
For the first two steps preliminary works have been performed (see Fig. 8). For characterizing the flow and thermal field a realistic model of the isolated mixing unit was developed. This was later validated by experimentally determined mixing temperatures. Therefore, the maximum error was 3 %. For simulating the reaction, the global reaction was used. The resulting reaction profiles could then be interpreted.
After that the particle formation through precipitation of the aqueous metal oxide is simulated. Therefore, the solubility of the metal oxide in the interesting range of pressure and temperature is required. In a first step the nucleation and growth rate are taken as constant values. With this assumption first particle size distributions can be simulated.
First results for the calculation of the solubility of salts in H2O in the typical range of process parameters for the CHTS process are shown in the following and taken from the master’s thesis of M. Zürn [1].
Fig. 9: Influence of the model of Sue, Arai and Adschiri [2] (SAA) and the revised model of Helgeson, Kirkham and Flowers [3] (rHKF) on the calculated equilibrium constant for the dissociation of NaCl in H2O |
Fig. 10: Equilibrium constants for Na2SO4: K1 - dissociation, K2 - precipitation |
|
Fig. 11: Equilibrium constants for NaCl: K1 - dissociation, K2 - precipitation |
Fig. 12: Influence of pressure on the estimated solubility for NaCl, according to the proposed method of Masoodiyeh [4] |
Modification
In addition to the performed experiments, surface modification tests for stabilizing metaloxide nanoparticles in organic solvents have been done. The following scheme shows the basic principles:
Fig. 13: Scheme of the surface modification of metaloxide nanoparticles in dependency of the amount of used organic acid, according to [5]
For stabilizing metaloxide nanoparticles in organic solvents the particles are surface modified during their synthesis by an organic acid. Therefore, the metal salt solution and the organic acid are mixed before they enter the mixing unit. Fig. 13 shows the different cases during particle formation. If the metal salt solution is not mixed with an organic acid (a) the common particle formation takes place and all surfaces grow regularly. Once a moderate amount of organic acid is mixed with the metal salt solution (b) the organic ligands attach to the {001} surface of the particle what causes a cubic morphology of the particles. If the amount of organic acid is high the organic ligands attach to each surface of the particle and the particle growth is inhibited.
By selecting the amount of organic acid, the morphology of the particles can be changed or their growth can be inhibited.
Literature:
[1] M. Zürn: Theoretische Untersuchung des Löslichkeitsverhaltens von Metallsalzen in nahe- oder überkritischem Wasser mit Hilfe unterschiedlicher Modelle (2019) Master’s thesis, KIT
[2] K. Sue, T. Adschiri, K. Arai: Predictive Model for Equilibrium Constants of Aqueous Inorganic Species at Subcritical and Supercritical Conditions Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. (2002) 41, 3298-3306
[3] J.C. Tanger, H.C. Helgeson: Calculation of the thermodynamic and transport properties of aqueous species at high pressures and temperatures: revised equations of state for the standard partial molal properties of ions and electrolytes, Am. J. Sci. 288 (1988) 19-98
[4] F. Masoodiyeh, M. R. Mozdianfard, J. Karimi-Sabet: Solubility estimation of inorganic salts in supercritical water, J. Chem. Thermodyn. (2014) 260–268
[5] Zhang et al.: Colloidal Ceria Nanocrystals: A Tailor-Made Crystal Morphology in Supercritical Water, Advanced Materials 19 (2007) 203 – 206